The scariest stories in Central FL

We hope you’re ready to sleep with the lights on.

Feature Image
Table of Contents

Look alive, Lakeland. We’re telling some scary stories. Keep reading for four of the most haunted spots + terrifying tales in and around Lakeland. Read on… if you dare.

The Mann House | 1424 Lakeview Rd., Lake Wales

A yellow house with two cars in the yard.

The Lake Wales home features on Unsolved Mysteries looks like any other house.

Image via Google Maps

If you’ve ever watched Unsolved Mysteries, you might have recognized a familiar spot on Season 6, Episode 6the Mann House. The Mann family was haunted by a female spirit in the 1990s and soon began suffering from headaches, hearing strange voices, and even had paranormal investigators visit. You can watch the full episode here; it starts at the two-minute mark.

The Stanford Inn Bed & Breakfast | 555 E. Stanford St., Bartow

Screen Shot 2021-08-12 at 12.59.13 PM

555 E. Stanford St. | Screenshot via Google Maps

Remember the house from “My Girl?” It was once believed that a “noisy” apparition of the former owner inhabited the former b&b. Doors would also allegedly close on their own, and disembodied footsteps had been heard on the staircase.

Allen Spivey Hall, Florida Southern College | 111 Lake Hollingsworth Dr., Lakeland

A red brick building

Could this dorm really have some ethereal residents?

Photo via Flickr

“My freshman year at FSC living in the Allen Spivey dorm building we heard a few things go bump in the night. The rumor was that a little boy haunted the building and was in the attic…at night you could hear something up there like someone was playing.” — Reader Jessica L.

Old Polk County Courthouse | 100 East Main St., Bartow

Screen Shot 2021-08-12 at 1.04.44 PM

The courthouse today | Screenshot via Google Maps

Built in 1909 on the foundations of the original courthouse, the Old Polk County Courthouse’s history dates back to the early 1880s. Haunted claims at this location include screams from the basement, apparitions on the second-floor rotunda, a “Lady in White” on the second floor, and numerous cold spots on the first floor.

Have another scary story we should tell in the dark? Send it our way, we’re feeling brave.

More from LALtoday
Shaken or stirred? Either one works, as long as it’s zero-proof. Check out this list of alcohol-free cocktails — mocktails — in Swan City.
Learn how artists Gillian Fazio and Katerina Santos plan to drench Lakeland in color through its first-ever mural festival, and how small businesses + muralists can get in on the artistic action.
Prep for the convention with events, guests, and exhibitions we wouldn’t miss.
With a Victorian vibe and shaved snow desserts, Vampire Penguin could become your newest downtown haunt.
Whether you’re looking for your next leisure read, a book for the whole family, or a thrilling fictional novel, we’ve got a list of books written by local authors in Lakeland.
We hear readers’ hopes for future Lakeland eateries all the time. Now, we’re compiling them all into a restaurant wishlist to see which foodie dreams come true.
From improving quality of life to wins for local businesses, find out how Lakeland measured up in last year’s rankings.
Avelo Airlines announced plans for two additional aircraft at its Lakeland International Airport base, as well as more flights on its schedule.
Create the city you want to live in by applying to serve in these volunteer roles.
Airbnb released its travel trends predictions for the year — here’s how you can take part, starting in Lakeland.