Support Us Button Widget

Haunted landmarks in Polk County

If you’ve ever felt a chill in your spine when frequenting these locales around Lakeland, there’s likely a good reason.

Annie Pfeiffer Chapel

Read the terrifying tales of these landmarks around Lakeland — if you dare.

Photo by @thelaltoday

Table of Contents

In the spirit of the Halloween season, we’re digging into the haunting side of history behind some of Polk County’s landmarks. Think you know all there is to know about these iconic spots? You’ll have to read on to find out — if you dare.

The Polk Theatre

This historic venue is reportedly home to three ghosts ranging from different time periods in the theater’s past. Get to know their stories, along with the many accounts of bone-chilling behavior that have occurred in the venue’s walls.

Florida Southern College

The hauntings on the campus of Florida Southern College are widely known in Lakeland, with the most notorious accounts about the Annie Pfeiffer Chapel + Buckner Theatre. According to rumor, the chapel’s choir screen wasn’t put in correctly and Frank Lloyd Wright’s apparition has been seen staring over it. At the Buckner Theatre, students have claimed to have seen doors shutting randomly or phantom hands in the curtains.

The Stanford Inn Bed & Breakfast

Though now permanently closed, it was once believed that a “noisy” apparition of the former owner inhabited this B&B featured in the 1991 film, “My Girl.” Doors would also allegedly close on their own, and disembodied footsteps had been heard on the staircase. The building is now home to Hope House, a home for expectant mothers.

Old Polk County Courthouse

Built in 1909 on the foundations of the original courthouse, the history of the Old Polk County Courthouse in Bartow dates back to the early 1880s. Haunted claims at this location include screams from the basement, apparitions on the second floor rotunda, a “Lady in White” on the second floor, and cold spots on the first floor.

Camilla Hall at Webber International University

Supposedly, a shadowy human figure lurks around the second floor of one of the girls-only dormitories at the university in Babson Park. According to rumors, only one student has ever seen the figure’s face right before he vanished before her eyes.

Reader submissions

We asked our readers which spots around Lakeland they felt could be haunted, and oh did they deliver some terrifying tales.

  • “There’s a ‘house’ off of Clarendon Avenue (south of North Crystal Lake Drive) that’s been engulfed in foliage since I was a kid in the 1970s. Supposedly a light comes on every night at midnight for one minute, then flashes for 30 seconds afterwards.” — Reader E. Dubs
  • “The old airport hangars at Tigertown are haunted by World War II veterans who were killed in action.” — Reader Gail D.
  • “Deceased former firefighters come back to hang out around the old firehouse on Memorial Boulevard.” — Anonymous Reader
  • “Harry’s Seafood Bar and Grille. The tunnels that supposedly run underneath the building and employees that have ‘unfinished business’, [it all gives] a general sense of [being haunted].” — Reader Michelle B.
More from LALtoday
There are both benefits and strict guidelines for homes in Lakeland’s seven historic districts. Does your home make the cut?
Check out our guide to the many meaningful murals you can find around our city.
Lakeland’s iconic bird mascot gets an annual visitor in the form of Canadian pelicans.
This is where you’ll find our readers grabbing a bite and catching a game.
Got a hot new fling? Hoping to spice things up with your longtime partner? We’re here to help plan your next date in Swan City.
Polk is full of special places to stay that offer guests a break from traditional motels and hotels — check out our favorites in and around Lakeland, Florida.
Strawberries, citrus, and sunflowers await at these U-pick spots where you’ll harvest your own bounty.
Whether you’re seeking a new romance or a fresh friendship, we’re asking readers where they go to meet people in Lakeland.
This home in the Beacon Hill Historic District has a story that spans over a century — in fact, it’s almost as old as the City of Lakeland itself.
Grab your boo or your bestie to celebrate love, friendship, and everything in between at these events around Swan City.