Support Us Button Widget

What do you want to see at the Eli Witt Cigar Co. in Downtown Lakeland?

eli-witt-cigar-building-preservation-p11-large

Rendering via Straughn Trout Architects

Table of Contents

No butts about it. The 95-year-old Gore Building in Downtown Lakeland (238 N. Massachusetts Ave.) — that once housed the Eli Witt Cigar Co. in the 1940s — may be getting new life breathed into it by local entrepreneurs.

The vision? A revamp of the space both externally and internally, opening up the two-stories of the 7,000+ square feet of the interior to include offices, restaurants, residential use + tenants, all while paying homage to the cigar company’s past.

While the building currently boasts Mediterranean-inspired, 20th-century terracotta tiles, several of the larger changes to the space involve:

  • Replacing the hipped roof, with a flat canopy roof — and a potential rooftop patio.
  • A new aluminum storefront + outdoor dining space
  • Adding on more parking spaces, accessible through Trader’s Alley
  • Outside signage, featuring cigar-themes shapes

To honor its place in the past, space will don the name, the Eli Witt Cigar Co. — as it housed a wholesale warehouse for tobacco tycoon and Tampa man, Eli Witt, in the 1940s.

If all goes according to plan, this anchor spot will be up for grabs. Here’s what some of you are already saying:

  • “Locally owned restaurants”@blacktrekking
  • “Please do something cool with it whoever gets it!!” @tenille2480
  • “I’m hoping for a healthy option bistro-style restaurant. Downtown could use a wellness food infusion.” @noemi.pareja

What retail store, business, restaurant, or space (local or national) would you like to see move in? Let us know below.

Question — #BetheBroker

More from LALtoday
The Comedy Cathedral is set to open by spring 2026 with entertainment, classes, and community events designed to keep Lakeland laughing.
Whether you’re looking for a charming bungalow or a stylish mid-century modern stay, Lakeland’s short-term rentals offer something for everyone looking for a staycation.
You won’t find an official Turkey Trot in Lakeland, but there are plenty of fun runs and nearby races to break a seasonal sweat.
Here’s a list of local restaurants open on Thanksgiving.
See who will take the stage in Plant City when the festival returns in February 2026.
The rebuilt store includes 55,701 sqft of space for shopping, dining, and relaxing. Scroll through photos from opening day.
Take a look inside the Ludd M. Spivey House, formerly home to Florida Southern College’s president who made a historic impact on the campus.
Over the next 10 days, we’re launching a reader-driven campaign to sustain what we do best.
Bookmark this guide for a curated list of events taking place each month that we’re most looking forward to.
The Lakeland Margarita Society hosts the Margarita Ball every November to raise money to provide Christmas gifts for local children.