Support Us Button Widget

Dine on history at Lakeland’s oldest restaurants

Take a bite of Lakeland’s past at these restaurants that have stood the test of time.

A bright, sunny photo of the Subs 'n Such restaurant sign, a local business with an old-fashioned feel.

If you’re looking for local businesses to support, here’s your sign.

Photo by LALtoday

If the Cracker Barrel rebrand taught us anything, it’s that people love a timeless classic. That sentiment certainly rings true in Lakeland, where several of the city’s oldest restaurants are still serving loyal fans after decades in the biz.

Reececliff Family Diner | 1934
This Dixieland diner has been dishing out comfort food for nearly a century. This isn’t the place to skip dessert — trust us, after your meal, you’re going to need a slice of pie.

Fat Jack’s Deli & Pub | 1963
If you’re a regular here, you’ve likely seen many of the same faces in the restaurant for years. Who can resist diner staples like a short stack of pancakes smothered in syrup, or a juicy hamburger right off the grill?

Jimbo’s Pit Bar B-Q | 1964
It’s a family affair at this Memorial Boulevard spot that claims to be the “best eatin’ in town since 1964.” Walk up or eat in to enjoy a barbecue plate or sandwich (plus a slice of pie).

LAL-Mister-Fish-laltoday

Find Mister Fish near the Lakeland Public Library on Lake Morton.

Photo by LALtoday

Mister Fish | 1968
Catch a meal at this walk-up eatery that promises every nibble is a good bite. After all these years, Lakelanders still can’t get enough of its fried fish sandwich baskets.

Subs ‘n Such | 1977
Plan a lunch run to this sandwich stand just down the street from Reececliff. Order a classic sub, go big with a footlong, or opt for a salad. Whatever you choose, you’ll be on your way before you can sing “Yellow Submarine.”

A spread of Southern dishes, including fried fish and shrimp, collard greens, mashed potatoes, onion rings, and mac and cheese.

No matter what you order from Country Chicken ‘n Fish, it’s bound to be delicious.

Country Chicken ‘n Fish | 1983
It’s all in the name here. Head to Kathleen Road for a box full of Southern-style fried chicken, fish, and your favorite sides. The owners say you can’t skip the chicken gizzards, either.

Mitchell’s Coffee House | 1998
You can’t talk about long-running eateries and not mention Lakeland’s first coffee shop. This downtown staple has paved the way for dozens of cafes over the years, and it’s still serving favorites like Coca-Cola cake + I Dream of Jeannie lattes after more than 25 years.

Which other restaurants have you been patronizing for decades? Fill us in, and we may feature it in our newsletter.

More from LALtoday
Keep an eye out and perhaps you’ll see one of these cryptid creatures in Lakeland — or maybe it will see you.
Could this be the real estate deal of the century? Learn how Publix is buying two downtown buildings for $10 each — and what you could get for that same price.
Find discounted clothing, accessories, shoes, and home goods at this national retailer’s first Lakeland location.
Pack your reusable shopping bags, because we’ve rounded up seven farmers markets around Lakeland, FL.
Due to the Moving Florida Forward Initiative, new I-4 express lanes are coming nine years in advance between I-75 and County Line Road.
Do you prefer to live in the past, or are you looking ahead to the future? Compare a 1925 home with a newly built house that just hit Lakeland’s real estate market.
In the mood to bust a move? Shimmy down to these local spots and events for open dance floors, performances, and dancing lessons.
Find a parking spot and walk to each of your favorite restaurants in the Shoppes at Lake Miriam Crossing plaza on South Florida Avenue.
Does your neighborhood go all out with decorations? Is it known as the street for full-size candy bars? Add it to our map of trick-or-treat destinations.
As Lakeland continues to grow, we’re keeping an eye on upcoming developments and recently opened businesses.