5 local spots for seasonal pies + treats in Lakeland, FL

Mitchell’s “Tri-Pie” | Photo via @mitchellscoffeehouse

Table of Contents

With Thanksgiving just around the corner, there’s no time to waste, so we’ll cut to the chase. We present: five local spots to buy your Thanksgiving pie, plus a few other local favorites

Born and Bread Bakehouse, order online | $29 | Whether it’s a classic pumpkin pie or brown butter apple pie, a truly local Florida Thankful (Key Lime) pie, or a gluten-free + vegan Cherry Crumble Pie, Born and Bread has you covered.

Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie | Photo via @bornandbreadfl

Bandidas Test Kitchen, order online | $35 | If you’re looking to bring something to the dinner table that will keep your guests talking, order one of Bandidas’ unique creations. Their pitaya pie (aka dragonfruit) boasts a “sweet and tart” flavor profile, similar to key lime pie, and is also available gluten-free. Other options include the pineapple sesame pie and the figgy pear gingerbread pie.

Heritage 715, order online | $30 | Now through Nov. 14, you can order an apple crumble, cherry crisp, pecan, or pumpkin pie. Other offerings include pumpkin bundt cake and carrot cake

Pumpkin pie with white chocolate drizzle | Photo via @heritage.seven15

Honeycomb Bread Bakers, order online | $24 | Head to Honeycomb Bread Bakers’ online pre-order form and order a southern pecan pie, classic apple pie, or a pumpkin tamarind pie. Orders close at 12 p.m. on Nov. 21 and can be picked up on Nov. 24 from 3-6 p.m. at their Lakeland or Winter Haven pickup location.

Mitchell’s Coffee House, 235 N. Kentucky Ave. | Prices vary | Everyone has different favorites, so how can you please them all? Enter: The Tri-Pie. Mitchell’s Tri-Pie is sectioned and filled with three flavors to satisfy all individuals around the table. And that’s not all. You can order any of the flavors mentioned above in their pie with a cinnamon bun crust, or a regular crust upon request. Place your order in the store or by giving them a call at 863-680-2944.

In addition to the pies mentioned, Cafe Zuppina will be serving up three large tarts, available for preorder (triple chocolate mousse, lemon meringue, and pecan) and Reececliff Family Diner will be serving up the following pies: pumpkin, sweet potato, apple, pecan, cherry, coconut cream, chocolate cream, and coconut custard.

Question